It Stays with You
Gone Baby Gone
I have struggled to sit down and write a review of this film for a while. I watched it all the way back in May, during the Ireland trip I took, as it was one of the movies offered on the overnight flight that I both hadn’t seen and had any interest in. This actually wasn’t the first time I’ve tried to watch Gone Baby Gone as I tried to get into it back in 2007 after it came out on DVD. The movie didn’t hook me at the time, and I set it aside on my shelf before moving on to other films. But stuck on a plane with nothing else to do, I finally was able to force myself to give it a chance.
Of note, this was also how I managed to sit through Chinatown. Same flight, with a lot of time on my hands and not much else to do. Thankfully I liked this one better than Chinatown.
Of course the film had a lot of buzz when it came out. It was the first directorial effort from Ben Affleck, who had gained fame (along with Matt Damon) for writing Good Will Hunting. The actor / producer had worked on a number of films before Gone Baby Gone, but this was the first one that he’d actually directed, and it marked a return for him to screenwriting as well. Suffice it to say, there were expectations for this movie that Gone Baby Gone had to rise to.
And it does, for the most part. The film is a solid piece of mystery filmmaking, a dark and soulful crime drama that Affleck handles with aplomb. It’s a solid slice of Bostonian crime storytelling, leaning hard into a city Affleck knows, a people he grew up with, and a local culture he can write about with lived-in experience. That all combines to make Gone Baby Gone feel like a very grounded, real take on the crime genre. But it doesn’t make the film any easier to watch as we focus on two cases of missing children, both of which don’t exactly end well. It’s a dark and, at times, pretty depressing movie, making it one that you can watch once, but that you might not want to watch again.
Casey Affleck, brother of Ben, stars as Patrick Kenzie, a local private detective who works with his business partner and girlfriend, Angie Gennaro (Michelle Monaghan). They are approached by Beatrice "Bea" McCready (Amy Madigan) and her husband, Lionel McCready (Titus Welliver), after their niece, Amanda McCready (Madeline O'Brien) goes missing. Her mother, Helene McCready (Amy Ryan) is a strung out drunk who barely kept her eye on the girl normally, and the previous night Helene had gone out for “just a few minutes” to the local dive bar, and when she got back Amanda was gone.
This initiates a massive search for the girl, but Bea and Lionel think that a different set of eyes, ones not from the police department, might turn up some clues. Patrick is hesitant to take the case, as he’s seen how missing children cases can go, but Angie insists they help. So they do, and they get some leads, hitting Patrick’s low-level criminal contacts (from when he was one of the ruffians before he turned legit) to shake some branches and see what comes loose. They actually managed to set up a swap with the alleged kidnapper, but something goes wrong and Amanda seemingly drowns in a deep lake. This sets Angie spiralling, and all Patrick can do is watch. But when a second missing child case comes up, Patrick feels drawn to look into it, despite even Angie saying it’s a bad idea. But what he turns up could make everything much, much worse.
Gone Baby Gone is an uneasy watch, but that’s by design. The opening act is hopeful, with the two detectives going about the case to try and get Amanda back. They think they can find her, that they can figure out what happened, and as they follow the clues and go down the path towards her, they assume that, in the end, Amanda will be reunited with her family. Sure, it’s not a family that is particularly great, what with her mother being a junky, but she does have an aunt and uncle that care for her so she might turn out okay once she’s brought home.
Except that isn’t what happened. That first act ends with the detectives seemingly losing the girl (although there are twists I won’t spoil that complicate that), and from that point forwards the film turns somber, darker, letting its leads wallow in this version of Boston they now find themselves living in. They tried to do a good thing, they failed, and not that failure sits on them like a pile of bricks, with the characters unable to push their way out or through because there’s no exit from this new reality. The luster of their old world view has been permanently tarnished.
Making this film work is a team effort, but some strong credit absolutely has to go to the leads. Caset Affleck grounds the film with his detective, a guy that is good at playing for his clients but then is also able to worm his way in and hang out with the darker elements. Monaghan gives the film heart, and when hers is crushed by the loss of Amanda, Monaghan makes you feel it. Together these two turn in soulful turns that make the story stick and get you to feel what they’re feeling as the film plays out.
But then credit is also due to Ben Affleck, who wrote and directed the film and handles it all with aplomb. His version of Boston feels lived in, not just because it was filmed in South Boston, but also because this is a city he knows, and loves, and grew up in. The city feels like a real place, and not just a movie set, and the actors feel like Bostonians. Their dialogue feels real, the locations have real weight and grime, and it all combines to suck you into this place and time and make you feel rooted within it.
It is honestly a masterfully made film, one that keeps you guessing even as the first case ends, the second case picks up, and the twists and turns continue. Affleck has an assured eye, not flashy but steady, and he gets great performances from all of his actors that feel real. That’s not always easy for a director to do, and considering this was Affleck’s first time in the director’s chair, it’s an impressive turn. You can see why Affleck went on to direct a few more movies, including the very well received Argo (which won Best Picture at the 2012 Academy Awards). Affleck has a talent for this.
I just wish Gone Baby Gone was a film I actually wanted to watch. It is so dark and depressing and grimy that at a certain point you want it to stop. Not because it’s poorly made but because you know that the journey you’re going on is not going to end well for just about anyone. It’s not a sick or depraved movie (this isn’t a Hostel, for example), but the unrelenting nature of the film, as it begins to wallow in the filth, makes it harder to watch. You’re watching people fall apart, losing themselves in depression, in their jobs, in anything that can give them meaning, and while it’s very well executed that doesn’t make it something to watch again and again. Once is certainly enough.
Gone Baby Gone is a very good movie, and I’m glad I finally sat down and watched it so I could appreciate what it had to offer. But in the future I am far more likely to watch Argo, which is a crowd pleaser, than this Affleck-directed film. This one actually might be the better movie (when comparing Gone Baby Gone and Argo), but it leaves you feeling so grimy afterwards that you want a shower. Congrats to Affleck for that, but I think I’m good not having to sit through that again.